Thứ Bảy, 13 tháng 10, 2007

When journalism and ethics cross paths




Bài viết đầu tiên bằng tiếng Anh đăng trên Thanh Niên Daily. Dạo này bận quá chả sắp xếp viết thêm được hic hic. Nội dung dạng text bên dưới.




When journalism and ethics cross paths

BY VIET PHUONG

(TN-BANGKOK) No journalist can avoid questions about ethics in their line of work. I am no exception. I thought I had all the answers until my little sister asked me a tough question that’s been bothering me ever since.

We’d had these kinds of discussions before. “If you were reporting in a disaster area, would you save someone in danger, or let them die to take their picture?” she’d ask. “That’s easy, of course I’d save them,” I’d confidently respond. But this time she asked me, “What about a protestor? What if someone was trying to burn himself? Would you stop him?” At that moment, I could find no response for her. It made me think of an experience where the very thing she spoke of happened to me. I was standing at the Democracy Monument in downtown Bangkok. It was a few days before the referendum on the new Thai constitution that was held last August. The leader of a group of protestors against the junta-backed constitution planned to create a media event by slashing his arm in front of a crowd at this very public monument.

Anti-riot police were deployed to stop him and control the crowd. I overheard a police officer angrily mutter, “He doesn’t have to cut himself like that. If he wants to commit suicide, I’ll lend him my gun!” The man climbed on top of a van parked in front of the monument and proceeded to slash his arm with a razor. The cut was deep. We could see the white bone inside as blood poured down his arm. Predictably, journalists started taking photos like mad. I was among them. Soon, the man started to get dizzy. The reporters didn’t want to stop taking pictures. Neither did I. As a protestor tried to bandage his arm, a journalist cried out, “Wait! Let us take a few more photos!” The man was only able to stand for another minute before he had to be rushed to the hospital. Is it ethical to encourage a man who’s almost collapsed from loss of blood to not go to the hospital so the press can document it?

I didn’t have a concrete answer for my sister. “It depends,” I told her. In the end, these are issues I will probably always struggle with as a journalist. But that doesn’t mean I won’t stop searching for the answer.

4 nhận xét:

  1. The Gioi Nghe Thuat21:53 13 tháng 10, 2007

    HiFrankie
    I like this article, and your sister is very smart. But if I'm a journalist I stick with my job as a journalist.If they want to kill them self, let them. How many can you save.
    Do your part every one happy. 1.you are not risking your life 2.your not risking your job. 3.he got what he want
    Pierre

    Trả lờiXóa
  2. I was taught to go ahead and take the pictures although someone might be in danger at the moment, kekeke...Thats how they teach me about journalism ethics.

    Trả lờiXóa
  3. That's thing each journalist must learn from experiencing. No school can teach us. Truth is always the clown. I'm sorry, the cloud!

    Trả lờiXóa
  4. Same stories told by anthropologists in the old days: save the tribal guys from harming themselves by their own customs or just let them be so that anthropologist finish the study?
    So true, it's a dilemma, face it and better have a good reason why you chose to act this and not otherwise. Save one right now or (your work is to)document and it will save more? Sometimes it is the matter of conscience when intelligence knows not.

    Trả lờiXóa